Happy new year, everyone! Now that the calendar year has rolled over, I'm bringing you the first of my "best of" posts for 2025. I'm going to start with television. (Now that I'm doing that one for the third time, I think it can be called an annual tradition.) Here are the 10 best 2025 shows I watched, with some honorable mentions.
10) Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. (Season 3) I'm probably fudging things a little to sneak this onto my list. There seems to be wide agreement that season 3 wasn't as good as the first two... but that's in part because those first two seasons set such a high bar. We still got 10 reliably "good" episodes, even if none were all-time greats. It's bonkers that they're ending this show after an abbreviated season 5. (Nearly as bonkers as it is to realize that there have been as many different Star Trek series in the last decade as there were in the 50 years before that.)
9) Only Murders in the Building. (Season 5) This show has always been reliably fun, with Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez making a surprisingly entertaining trio. Season 5 marked an unexpected creative resurgence, with one of the show's more clever mysteries, escalating personal stakes, and smart casting of several conventionally dramatic actors in more comedic roles. There's still juice to squeeze from this fruit.
8) Ghosts. (Seasons 4 and 5) This network show is still doing things "old school," with a 20-episode season running from September to May. So maybe it's something of a cheat to take parts of two different seasons (that ran in calendar year 2025) and give that a slot on this list. But I think the writers keep finding fun stories to tell with their big ensemble cast, and I keep laughing out loud every episode. I used to be unsure who my favorite character on the show was, but it's no contest anymore: Rebecca Wisocky is a comedy assassin as Hetty.
7) A Man on the Inside. (Seasons 2) This Ted Danson vehicle followed up a warm and funny season 1 with an even better season 2. As with any Michael Schur TV show, this one is great at balancing jokes with genuine sentiment. And even though season 2 moved from the retirement home to a new setting, the story found clever ways to incorporate favorite characters from the first season.
6) Alien: Earth. (Season 1) Series creator Noah Hawley achieved what had for over a decade now seemed impossible: he made an Alien prequel that was actually good. Alien: Earth was a perfect blend of honoring what was great about the original and building out the story with more evil corporate scheming and terrifying monsters. I don't know that I've ever truly looked forward to a new installment of the Alien franchise, but now I will for season 2 of this show.
5) Paradise. (Season 1) From Dan Fogelman, the man who with This Is Us made a Lost-like puzzle box out of a family drama (but with actual answers!), comes another puzzle box in the form of a post-apocalyptic mystery. That's a more expected blend, but Paradise is anything but "conventional." Sterling K. Brown is the intense lead of this intense suspense-thriller. And season 2 is just a few months away.
4) Poker Face. (Season 2) I've decided I will watch anything Natasha Lyonne is in. I'll be sorry that it won't be new episodes of this fantastic homage to Columbo, but I'm glad we got as much as we did. (Yes, I've heard the rumors that creator Rian Johnson wants to reboot the show somewhere with Peter Dinklage as the star. That sounds great too!)
3) Slow Horses. (Season 5) We're running out "Slough House" books by Mick Herron, but this is great fun while it lasts. Pretty much the only shortcoming of season 5 was how prominently it featured a "best in small doses" secondary character who seems better used as comic relief. But for as long as Gary Oldman wants to keep playing Jackson Lamb (with the rest of this exceptional cast), I'll be there.
2) Pluribus. (Season 1) I reviewed this show very recently, so I don't have more to add. I'll just reiterate that it's a perfect union of great writing and acting, a high sci-fi concept that's also easy to understand, and superb production that hides how incredibly difficult it must have been to make everything work. If there wasn't one more show that even more perfectly met the moment, Pluribus would be an easy #1.
1) Star Wars: Andor. (Season 2) The conclusion of Andor was as satisfying as fans of season one dared to hope it would be. Andor was indisputably the best Star Wars television show, and pretty much the perfect television show for right now, regardless of genre. It's impossible to completely set aside childhood nostalgia for the original movie trilogy, of course... but if I could, I'd probably admit it's the best Star Wars, period.
And a few honorable mentions:
- Season 2 of Silo straddled both 2024 and 2025. Because I put it in my top 10 list for 2024, I omitted it here. But had it been in contention, I'd have given it the #5 slot.
- Stranger Things was never as good as it was in its first blockbuster season, but season 5 was the best since then. It heightened and highlighted all of the best things about the show, with hugely emotional scenes giving the young cast its biggest chance ever to shine -- with especially great moments throughout the season for Finn Wolfhard, Sadie Sink, Maya Hawke, and Noah Schnapp. (Genre TV rarely gets Emmy award, but I say Schnapp in particular deserves it.) The season also highlighted everything... let's say less than great about the show, like wild intuitive leaps to progress plot, and dead end story lines to occupy characters from its sprawling cast. (Adding Linda Hamilton to do basically nothing was especially egregious.) Overall though, the finale itself felt to me like it "understood the assignment" and went out on a high.
- Because of strange contract provisions or something, the 10 episodes of South Park released in 2025 were officially billed as two back-to-back five episode seasons, 27 and 28. Collectively, they were a scorching parody of the political state of things in the United States. I did feel some diminishing returns as the ongoing story rolled along... but I still laughed.
- I kept hearing I needed to watch The Studio and The Pitt. I never got around to either, if you're wondering why they're not on my list.
Looking ahead to 2026, I'm anticipating more Star Trek: Strange New Worlds (and, to a lesser degree, the imminent debut of Starfleet Academy). Speaking of "scorching parody," we'll have the final season of The Boys. We'll have two different seasons of Game of Thrones spin-offs -- and no, that's not as exciting as it may once have been, but I won't pretend I'm not going to watch. Plus, other shows previously in my top 10 lists are bringing new seasons, including Paradise, Shrinking, and Slow Horses.
So much to watch, so little time...