There
are many movies that, in retrospect, turned out to be of major
significance. But few movies said to be "important" in advance can live
up to expectations. And the 2016 version of Ghostbusters was saddled
with some impossible "important" baggage -- what started out as yet
another 80s remake somehow transformed into a litmus test for feminism.
In
that I only just got around to seeing the movie, you might say I failed
that test. My defense would be simply that I never bought into the
notion of it being a test. This movie's stars -- Melissa McCarthy, Kristen
Wiig, Kate McKinnon, and Leslie Jones -- have all been hilarious in
other places; this movie didn't need to prove me that they (or
certainly, women in general) are funny. Still, funny people can team up
to make an unfunny movie, and my read of the critics and the trailers
suggested this should be a "wait for home video" movie for me.
That
turned out to be exactly the right call. There was enough good here to
make the movie worth seeing, and enough bad that I'm glad I didn't pay
theater prices for it. This split breaks down almost straight down the
middle of the movie, in fact. The first half of the film serves up a
number of laughs (and still more grins). But then the tension between
comedy and big budget visuals breaks in the other direction. The final
act is a nonstop procession of mindless blockbuster action; there's
plenty of eye-popping visuals, but it's all wanton destruction justified
by technobabble slathered on thicker than a bad Star Trek episode.
Leslie
Jones nearly steals the show with several laugh out loud line readings.
Kate McKinnon leans as far as she can into the bizarre character she's
been given, squeezing out more humor than exists on the page. But
Melissa McCarthy and Kristen Wiig aren't given chances to shine at all.
Saddled with the worst of the plot track-laying, they fall well short of
their performances in Bridesmaids (to say nothing of their separate
work). They have to do all the heavy lifting for this story, rarely
getting a chance to riff.
In
a cruel irony, because the men don't further the plot much in this
feminist movie, they're often free to just be funny. Chris Hemsworth is
given most of the movie's best material as the Ghostbusters' "him-bo"
receptionist. Zach Woods (of The Office and Silicon Valley) has a tiny
role in the first few minutes of the film, but somehow finds many of the
biggest laughs in that span. Even Charles Dance gets to shade his stern
Tywin Lannister schtick toward comedy in a brief role.
One
bonus in waiting to see this on video was that I got to experience some
interesting formatting they did for the Blu-ray. The bulk of the movie
was presented in the 2.35:1 aspect ratio. (For those not up on the
numbers, that means that even on today's standard widescreen TVs, there
are black bars on the top and bottom of the screen.) But during key
moments -- involving ghost slime, lightning arcs, proton pack shots, and
the like -- the visual effects actually broke the frame and extended
through the bars to the edge of the screen, creating a sort of
no-special-equipment-needed 3D effect. In addition, a short, key
sequence at the end of the movie was presented full screen (16:9),
omitting the black bars entirely. It's interesting to me that a movie
which hadn't been a runaway box office success nevertheless had still more money spent on it to create new effects for home video.
A
movie worthy of these stars could have been an A. The same movie that
at least didn't descend into mindless destruction for the finale could
have been maybe a B+. As it is, though, I think Ghostbusters lands at a
B-. It's just in the "watchable" zone for those predisposed to want to,
but there's almost certainly not enough here to convert anyone already
set against it.
1 comment:
I noticed the letterbox breaking effects, too, and thought that was pretty darned cool.
Didn't take it above a "C" for me, though.
I REALLY wanted to like this one (hey, the original -- especially Venkman's skeezy crap at the start with the coed -- wasn't exactly High Cinema), but I was pretty let down, despite all hope to the contrary. :-/
Post a Comment