While I've been posting a "year in games" review and "year in movies" review for a long while now, this is only the second time I've done a "year in TV" review.
Comparing my "Top 10 Lists" from 2024 and 2023, I'd say that the 2023 is a slightly stronger and more even list all the way through #10. But if it were just a "Top 5" list, 2024 comes out ahead -- the "best of the best" was better in 2024 than the year before.
What 5 or 10 shows am I talking about?
10) The Big Door Prize. (Season 2) Season 2 of the now-cancelled series was a notable step up from season 1. The story of a town-wide journey of self-exploration (or, as some in the show call it, "selfploration") had plenty of moving moments, sweet sentiments, and helpful observations on life -- and plenty of compelling characters just struggling to find their authentic selves. I'm sorry the series won't ever reach its natural conclusion... but then, self-actualization is a life-long process that never truly ends, isn't it?
9) What We Do in the Shadows. (Season 6) This show
arguably went one season too long (a notion hilariously commented upon
in the series finale). And there was certainly never any "learning or
growing" among the characters (also commented upon). But the show keep
squeezing funny juice out of its highly specific (and you would think
limited) premise. Without this season, we wouldn't have the hilarity of
Cravensworth's Monster, Guillermo's corporate job, or Nandor's moody
crisis of self-worth. Even if the show did last one season too long, it ended while it was still really great.
8) Ghosts. (Season 3... and part of season 4) This sitcom remains the best thing happening on old-fashioned, non-streaming, over-the-air television. The abbreviated season 3 (shortened by Hollywood strikes and multiple pregnancies in the cast) wasn't quite up to the level of the first two seasons -- yet still very good. And so far, season 4 is fully back to its reliably hilarious hijinks. The series continues to flesh out its sprawling cast of characters in surprising ways that make you actually care about everyone beyond just the jokes -- which make me laugh out loud multiple times every episode.
7) Silo. (Season 2) The new season of Silo is still running, split across 2024 and 2025, but it should certainly count on at least one of those lists. It's
working in an area of the source novels that's been far more challenging
to adapt than season one, yet it has continued to excel. It manages to make me feel a real
sense of jeopardy, even though I've read the story. It's kept the
narrative alive outside of Juliette's immediate field of view, and Steve
Zahn has given a strong performance as the challenging-on-the-page new
character of Solo. For all these reasons, and the continued great performances of Rebecca Ferguson, Tim Robbins, and more, this series
gets a spot on my list.
6) Masters of the Air. I didn't have much faith that a follow-up to the tremendous Band of Brothers (and "pretty good" The Pacific), coming years and years later, could be great. But it absolutely was. Perhaps this long was needed for visual effects on television to reach a point to tell this story. In any case, these tales of another theater of World War II were impactful, at times harrowing, and moving.
5) Dead Boy Detectives. We got only one season of this delightful show... which arrived just before disappointing (but credible) accusations against creator Neil Gaiman made the rounds. Despite those two dark clouds over the show, there was still so much good. A tight core of delightful characters, each compelling portrayed. "One-off" stories skillfully juggled with an ongoing storyline. To me, these few episodes were light years better than the show that loosely spawned it (The Sandman).
4) Star Trek: Lower Decks. (Season 5) I can understand ending Star Trek: Discovery. Star Trek: Picard always felt like a limited thing anyway. But it is mind-boggling to me that Lower Decks isn't going to continue for years and years to come. At least if it had to end, it went out on top in every conceivable way -- with the best season of the series, the best final season of any Star Trek since Deep Space Nine, and a jam-packed, celebratory finale episode that concluded everything well, while still leaving room for the Powers That Be to come to their senses some day. We're fortunate that there was so much Star Trek in this new age of Star Trek that there was room enough for something like this -- seemingly irreverent, while subtly laying claim to being one of the most authentically Star Trek series of all.
3) Slow Horses. (Season 4) Every season of Slow Horses has been superb, but this season made a strong case for being the best so far, with a plot-twisty story about an agent on the lam, a deadly terrorist attack, a secret past coming back to haunt one of the heroes, and more I'd rather not even hint at. The cast remains uniformly fantastic, with Gary Oldman in particular doing quite possibly career-best work (in a truly exceptional career) -- Jackson Lamb is one of television's all-time great characters.
2) Shrinking. (Season 2) There's always some sitcom somewhere on
television doing a masterful job of blending laughs with serious drama;
Shrinking is the best there is right now, and I dare say very few shows
have ever done it so well. The second season was even stronger than the excellent first.
The cast is amazing, top to bottom. Especially amazing things happen when Harrison Ford actually appears vulnerable on
camera. And actors who have really only been known for comedy (Jason Segel and recurring season two guest star Brett Goldstein) show some surprising dramatic chops in this run too.
1) Heartstopper. (Season 3) This British teen romance drama centered on LGBT+ relationships was stronger than ever in its newest season. It dealt most effectively and emotionally with mental health struggles, highlighted trans issues at a very important time for that in the real world, and featured best-yet performances from its young cast. The show was devastating and hopeful in turns, and my favorite television of 2024.
A couple of honorable mentions:
- Shōgun would have been #11 on my list. I thought it was solid overall, but it lost me a bit in the finale -- hence it just missing my list.
- I'm five years behind on this, but I began watching The Morning Show in 2024, and season 1 was excellent. If this were a list of "top 10 shows I watched this year" and not specifically "shows from 2024," it would actually take the number 3 slot. (When I catch up on the whole series to date, I'm sure I'll dedicate a blog post to it.)
There's already a lot of 2025 television to look forward to: season 2 of Severance arrives in just a couple of weeks, season 2 of Star Wars: Andor will be amazing even if it's only half as good as the first, ditto for season 2 of The Last of Us... plus an Alien series from TV genius Noah Hawley is set to debut, a new Star Trek series should arrive at some point, and perhaps some new favorite I haven't even heard of yet.