The xenophobic villain Paxton has bunkered on Mars, where he threatens Starfleet with annihilation. And he's forcing Trip to help, by threatening the lives of T'Pol and their infant daughter. But there may yet be a way to sneak a rescue team past the base's sensors -- if Hoshi can take command and buy them enough time.
I'll spoil the ending here: I think this is the best episode of Star Trek: Enterprise. It's absolutely wild that they "waited" until the end to give that to us... but I guess you want a television show to go out on a high.
First, I can think of no other episode that gives such meaningful moments to each of the characters. Archer is in full swashbuckling mode, taking on the baddie in a high stakes brawl. But the moral stakes of the fight matter too: Archer and Paxton are both very much the sons of their fathers, embodying opposing ideals.
T'Pol gets in touch with her emotions more than ever before, bonding with her baby in a touching one-on-one scene, then defiantly standing up to her captor with a fantastic "movie badass" comeback. (When Paxton admits "I’m not the first significant leader not to live up to his ideals," she spits back: "You’re not significant!")
When Trip's love of T'Pol and their daughter is wielded against him, Trip finds an alternative to helping Paxton -- sneakily sabotaging the villain's superweapon.
Phlox has a pair of touching scenes that remind us that John Billingsley was the strongest actor on this show, without contest. (And I say this as a Quantum Leap fan; sorry, Scott Bakula.) Phlox mourning the loss of T'Pol and Trip's child as though she were his own could seem so performative, but instead it legitimately moved me. And the later comfort he gives the couple -- that they could have a child some day -- is almost as strong.
Reed goes back to his Section 31 boss one more time, and manages to get information from him without any apparent concession on his part. He finally does something right, and gets the upper hand!
Mayweather turns out to not have been honeypotted in the previous episode after all! At least, not by a true villain. His former flame is actually an undercover Starfleet Intelligence agent. Not only does the information he gets from her help save the day, but then he gets to do some fancy flying, piloting a rescue team down to Mars. He's even the one who ultimately identifies the mole aboard Enterprise.
And Hoshi Sato gets to sit in the freaking captain's chair! I'm not sure it makes a lick of sense for her to be there, but I stop caring about that the moment she starts giving orders with confidence, standing up to an admiral, and doing the right thing that wins the day.
All this great character stuff is supported by a classic Star Trek moral message -- yet one that's presented with a deft subtlety that classic Star Trek rarely managed. We're shown, not told, how bankrupt the ideology of Paxton and others like him is: how internally inconsistent and hypocritical. He hates aliens and wants them out of our solar system... but is happy to personally benefit from their technology. One of his supporters is mad about how much aliens interfere, while being simultaneously upset that aliens didn't interfere to stop a world war on Earth. And the ultimate horror of where all this alien interaction will lead? A human/alien hybrid baby!
Oh no. How awful.
The episode is also peppered with satisfying little moments acknowledging that this is the end of the line for these characters. Look how far Hoshi Sato has come! Look how many planets Malcolm Reed has visited! Look at what T'Pol and Trip have come to mean to each other! Hell, even Soval has come a long way: standing up to lead a classic slow clap at the end of the episode. What can I say, it all works.
Other observations:
- The episode uses the recurring character of Kelby as a red herring: is he the mole aboard Enterprise? No, it turns out. But I think that would have been a more effective choice than making the spy be someone we've never met before.
- When Trip is locked up and has to break out, the musical score is odd -- very conspicuous synthesizer stings.
- It's a fun Easter Egg to make a Carl Sagan Memorial Station out of a defunct Mars rover.
I'll undermine the apparent love fest here a bit to say that even "the best episode of Enterprise" isn't worth any kind of A grade in my book. I think the show is still too action-driven compared to what I like Star Trek for. It squanders Scott Bakula. It often substitutes visual effects for good storytelling. But if Enterprise had been this decent on a regular basis? I wouldn't be down on it at all. I give "Terra Prime" a B+.










