During the Pegasus incident aboard the U.S.S. Enterprise-D, Commander William Riker is caught in a crisis of conscience. He seeks advice from Deanna Troi... but also from a holographic simulation of the NX-01 Enterprise and her crew. On the eve of the founding of the Federation, they must help the Andorian Shran rescue his kidnapped daughter. But one member of the Enterprise crew may trade their life in the effort.
The series finale of Star Trek: Enterprise is much maligned. Objectively, I understand why. It's the self-indulgent brain child of Rick Berman and Brannon Braga. Each was involved with the Star Trek franchise for nearly two decades, and seem to have convinced themselves that the end of Star Trek: Enterprise was going to be the end of all Star Trek. Yet the franchise had existed two decades before them; how hard was it to imagine that it might exist again after them? (In fact, a later incarnation of Star Trek would find exactly the right words to describe this viewpoint: "sheer fucking hubris.")
But...
I can't help but put on the rose-colored glasses, feel every bit of affection for Star Trek: The Next Generation, and extend a lot of grace for this episode that objectively doesn't deserve it. Yes, I know: the finale of Enterprise should not be a story where the main series characters exist only in service to a personal growth story for William Riker, a guest star. It absolutely should not be a story that kills off a character for a cheap pop of emotion, just because we know we'll never have to deal with the repercussions of that.
And yet, Jonathan Frakes is infinitely charming as Riker. His chemistry with Marina Sirtis as Troi is... well, I was going to say "undeniable," except that Star Trek: The Next Generation did deny it for seven seasons (even throwing Worf between them) before finally putting them together in the movies. I can't help it; I love seeing the banter between these two. I love seeing beautiful new CG shots of the Enterprise I grew up with. I love the quick audio cameo "appearance" by Brent Spiner as Data. I love the way the episode appeals to "deep cut" fans like me, slotting the story in with the continuity of a great Next Generation episode. I love the set re-creations of crew quarters, Ten Forward, a hallway, the briefing room, a turbolift (even if it doesn't look quite right), and more -- every bit as much as fans who grew up on original Star Trek must have loved the first re-creation of that original bridge. I love the subtle "full circle" of the first time we met Will Riker: he quickly sat down on the battle bridge to watch clips of Star Trek on Star Trek; now here at what the creatives assumed would be the last time we'd ever see him, he was once again watching clips of Star Trek on Star Trek (this time using a holodeck).
But I grew up on Star Trek: The Next Generation. What does this episode look like to someone who actually came to Star Trek through Enterprise? Undeniably, pretty shitty.
By setting this episode a decade later than the last, it already doesn't feel like the series we've been watching (never mind the Next Gen interlopers). The uniforms look wrong. The ship is being mothballed. After four seasons of "will they, won't they" between Trip and T'Pol, the final answer is "they won't?!" Come on!
Worst of all, I think, is the way they play games with the death of Charles "Trip" Tucker III. Troi tells us this is his last mission, setting up a feeble 20-minute "mystery" about how he's going to die. He takes a perilous fall on an alien planet... but no, that's not his death. It comes later in a weirdly impulsive moment of self-sacrifice. And it's so cheapened in so many ways. It's not clear that he's sacrificing for anything especially meaningful. It doesn't have a sense of finality, because Riker just rewinds his holodeck program to talk to Trip after witnessing his death. And we don't see any of Trip's friends mourn because Riker isn't interested in watching that bummer of a holodeck story.
Other observations:
- We're slamming Malcolm Reed right to the very end. Riker notes that he's "shorter than I thought."
- It's super creepy when Riker freezes the program to kiss T'Pol on the cheek. Like... we know this is what everyone is probably using the holodeck for, but we don't need to see it.
- We still never get to see what "Chef" looks like, because he's being played on a holodeck by Riker.
- Archer and Trip drink "to the next generation." A bit on the nose.
- One final CG-assisted smile from Dr. Phlox. It doesn't look nearly as unnatural as it did in the first episode of Enterprise.
- The episode ends with narrations of the classic Star Trek voice-over from Picard, Kirk, and Archer. A fitting end. At least, for a franchise. (Not that it was actually the end.)
I understand the instinct to approach "These Are the Voyages..." as a finale for 18 years of the Star Trek franchise. And it isn't terrible. But it isn't exactly good. It's certainly not what Enterprise deserved. Yet given my soft spot for The Next Generation? I'll give it a B-.
It feels a little weird to pick a "five best episodes" of the final season when so many were part of multi-episode arcs, but my picks would be "Terra Prime," "In A Mirror Darkly, Part I," "Affliction," "United," and "Divergence."
So, what to say about Star Trek: Enterprise as a whole? Well, I didn't love Voyager all that much either... but I can at least identify a couple of A- grade Voyager episodes. In my book, Enterprise never reached such heights. On the other hand, Enterprise was much more consistent; in particular, its final season (the best one) was better on average than any single season of Star Trek: Voyager. Enterprise might be the most "consistently fine" of all the Star Trek shows of its era. You don't have to tell people, "hang in there for the first season or two; it'll get better." Enterprise did get better late, but it also arrived out of the gate almost fully formed, as the show it would wind up being.
Is Enterprise the worst incarnation of all Star Trek? Well, now that we've had so many Star Trek series that only the most die-hard fan could even name them all -- probably not. Certainly not if you count the original Animated Series as "canon." But in a world where one can recognize that not every Star Trek series has to be specifically "for you?" Enterprise has a place. I enjoyed re-watching it.
....though I'll probably never do so again.













































